Well guys, my instincts were correct. As soon as I saw the first statue packaging with a smash corner, I insisted on a replacement. I didn't even care to open it to check as there was no doubt in my mind it was dropped. Well tonight I opened the first one I received from last week, and look what I find...
This is what I saw as soon as I opened the amazon shipping box:
McFarlane shipping box:
Corner of statue's box:
This was the second statue's damage, still unopened as of right now: