1 - Collectors edition of the year: Sonic Generations CE [PAL] - gorgeous edition, really love it
Comes with so much stuff and is just fabulous!
2 - Most Likely to appreciate in value: Zelda Skyward Sword Collector's Edition Bundle - sold out very fast, and as with all Zelda items, retains value and appreciates quickly! My close second would be the Uncharted 3 Explorer Edition.
3 - Best CE for a new franchise: Dead Island Treasure Edition - sadly I missed out on this but I'd definitely vote for this. The Red Edition was also pretty awesome
4 - Best Box Art: Deus Ex Human Revolution Collector's Edition - the gold on black is just stunning and it's a very nice box to look at, albeit simple. Simple, yet stunning.
5 - Best Bonus Item: Yakuza 4 Ichiban Box - speaks for itself. Such an amazing idea for a bonus item, and in terms of value, far beats the edition it was simply a bonus for!
6 - Best Unboxing Experience: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Collector's Edition - everything inside the box was a treat, from the AMAZING artbook to the gorgeous digipak to the outstanding statue (albeit with a shitty base, but the dragon is awesome), all of it just amazed me.
7 - Most Unique Package Design: Uncharted 3 Special Edition (the digipak which is also included in the Explorer Edition) - such an outstanding concept, making it like a journal. Beautiful.
8 - Most Unique Bonus item: Yakuza 4 Ichiban Box - As previously mentioned, just the best preorder bonus I've seen in a long time, maybe even EVER.
9 - Best CE Guide: The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword - love all of the Zelda CE guides, and this one is no exception.
10 - Best CE system: Limited Edition Gears of War 4 Xbox 360 - simply stunning. I think Onyxia's photograph on it is what makes me love it the most!