[Saturn]

1. Collector's Edition of the Year.
Sonic Generations CE for sure. It's the most beautiful/nostalgic/complete edition out there in recent times. Plus it was made available to many people and I think it's important when evaluating the best.

2. Most likely to appreciate in value
Dead Island Limited Treasure Edition. It's quite limited and doesn't come from your regular online retailer. It takes some effort to order from austria if you don't live there or dont understand the language and it was sold out way before being released.

3. Best CE for a New Franchise
Dead Island Limited Treasure Edition, yet again.

4. Best Box Art
Tough question. I'd say Xenoblade Chronicles bundle, I love the art.

5. Best Bonus Item
---
6. Best Unboxing Experience
Sonic Generations CE

7. Most Unique Package Design
Assasin's Creed Revelations Animus Edition

8. Most Unique Bonus Item
---

9. Best CE guide
---

10. Best CE system
---