Best and Worst Collector's Edition of 2011

[Madigan]

Originally Posted by Hans v Hube

Where is Duke Nukem forever balls of steel - collectors' edition?




Everything inside felt cheap (the poker chips vs say Fallout ones for example)

Including the game

[fattyuk]

I'll add pics later best :

uncharted EE
sonic generations
killzone 3 helghast edition

worst :

1 SAINTS ROW PLAY.COM PS3 VERSION
2 deus ex collectors edition
3 dead island red edition

uncharted for best digipack
uncharted for best guide

[Lemur]

Best CE:
1) Uncharted 3 Explorer Edition
2) Skyrim CE
3) Sonic Generations CE

Worst CE:
1) Dead Space 2 CE (Worst CE ever not just for the year)
2) Modern Warfare 3 Hardened Edition
3) Arcana Heart 3 Suggoi Oppai Fan Edition

Best digipak: Uncharted 3 Special Edition
Best steelbook: Deus Ex G2 (gorgeous steel)

Best guide: Skyrim Collector Guide

[Skoolstah]

Best CE of the year
1st - Sonic Generations Collector's Edition
http://collectorsedition.org/uploads...ic-540x373.jpg
Awesome set of extras.

2nd - Space Marine Collector's Edition
http://collectorsedition.org/uploads...to-540x389.jpg
Pretty hefty and great artbook in hardcover.

3rd - Batman: Arkham City Collector's Edition
http://collectorsedition.org/uploads...ksteady_00.jpg
Call me crazy, but I like the figure and Bluray movie, although the package wasn't super.


Worst CE of the year
1st - Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Hardened Edition
http://i.imgur.com/xUVs1.jpg
One word: Crap.

2nd - Dark Souls Collector's Edition
http://www.co-optimus.com/images/upl...tion-final.png
Felt kinda simple and somehow worse than Demon's Souls, although it included essentially the same stuff.

3rd - Lord of the Rings: War in the North Collector's Edition
http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/...L._AA1500_.jpg
I don't know why, but this one just irritates me to no end. Must be the figure.


Best Steelbook/digipack
1st - Uncharted 3 Steelbook
http://www.bluraysteelbooks.com/wp-c...s/dscf8962.jpg
Looks awesome with the embossed ring and stuff.