From Texas!

[Iwatasan]

There's a matching crease/whatever on the other side too. Watch this video and tell me it couldn't be re-sealed if it was done meticulously. Note how he uses the knife to slice right up to where the creases/whatever are on the Samus figure in question.



Then again, holding my amiibo under a lamp I was able to reproduce glare in those exact spots. Ask for close up photos of where the plastic meets the card at the top two corners. With two photos (from different angles) of the same spots it should be obvious whether the creases/whatever are actually glare or something more.