VGA grader legit?

[Gameshark]

What are your recommendations for grading your Sealed Collector's edition games? I hear VGA grader is popular in ebay, but is it worth the expensive cost?

Or just not have your games graded at all. Don't even know if it really matters.

[gurpswoo1]

It really depends on what you want to do.

Like myself I have graded a game to simply preserve and protect it. VGA cases are very good.

The popularity on eBay is mainly due to resellers using VGA to increase the price. In high grades the demand for them is high to charge the higher prices but for lower grades demand is lower.

In terms of reputation and reliability, VGA are somewhat new to the grading industry and as far as I'm aware they are quite secretive about their credentials. There have been cases when they have mistaken a a reseal for a real seal. They are very rare cases but it has happened. In the end if the end users thinks it's real I guess it doesn't really matter.

For anyone outside North america cost are horrific and would take a long time to recover the cost of a lower value game, It's easier to understand and grade when the item is of high value.

So if you have higher value items, that you think would get a 85+ grade then it's a good idea.

If you want to preserve them with out the grading cost then you could buy the VGA cases direct for less.

[DemonATX]

Everything is exactly as gurps says. I would definitely stick with just getting either your favorites graded or really rare high quality games graded. I myself like to get my favorite series graded, even though my Zelda II for NES has a hole in it and might not even get a silver rating....

But if you just want to preserve your games I would also recommend getting their cases or Alpha security cases(the kind they have at best buy, walmart, etc.)

[nipperkipper]

Originally Posted by gurpswoo1

In terms of reputation and reliability, VGA are somewhat new to the grading industry and as far as I'm aware they are quite secretive about their credentials.

Out of interest do you know of any other graders especially any closer to home

[gurpswoo1]

Sorry I don't know any, its something many collectors outside North America want.

There is another in the USA, but they are a complete disgrace and you must avoid them at all cost.

[vhal_x]

Can you open VGA grader boxes? Or would you have to smash it open xx

[jugolicious]

you can open the VGA boxes from the bottom =)

or atleast most of them are from the bottom

[vhal_x]

So, technically, you could get something minty mint reviewed, then when you receive it back with it's 90+ rating, switch it out with something in shittier condition (but not overly noticeable) and then close it, and sell it, claiming it is the good rating? xx

[evilvort3x]

i dont think so cos the case inside is sealed completely i THINK vhal?

[jugolicious]

the vga cases would just be sealed with a plastic bag and tapes.

if someone were to buy a vga graded item in the first place, it would probably be hard to trick that person with something of a lower grade.

i guess it would be possible to trick someone with a graded item of 95 with a 90, but that is a pretty complicated thing to do =/