Collector Edition of the year

[LowlyAssassin]

Shouldn't we first have a list of what must be in a CE
Sort of a check list
And then grade the CE's based on those criteria
As otherwise a lot of us will just go for our favourite game or the newest game (cough GTAV)

So
What makes a good CE?

• Artbook/Mini Art book
• replica of in game item
• Figure/ Statue
• steelbook

What I consider a good CE
Iis not what others would consider a good CE
As I don't want to see a figure or statue in a CE as they can be sold separately
And an art book can be sold separately

So my nomination is:
dead space 3 dev team edition
Because pretty much the entire CE is an in game replace (except for the stupid name plaque)



NiNo Kuni: Wizards Edition
Not worth the 100 GBP price tag but I love the artwork of the box and that they give you an in game replica wizards book which is an art book and a wizards game guide, bit for the price tag its not a lot really



But I also like these 2
Total war II: ROME
(for the replica trebuchet thing)



WATCHDOGS vigilante edition
for the hat and the mask / bit so many games have a CE with a piece of clothing so its not really anything special

So
And really in order to do these sort of thing
We should have had a grading criteria
Like a check list as mentioned and then grade that against the retail price
And it should have been done against every CE that was released as to keep it fair
As this feels a bit like
Let's just give an award to a 4th quarter / next gen blockbuster (well that's what it feels like to me)


But as a value for money bundle of items that ticks every box from the Essential CE list (but I am.biased here)
Art book
Statue/figure
Original soundtrack
Steelbook
Artwork in the style of the game
poster/lithographs/box canvas
It even includes an in game.replica of a flag and map