Videogames G2 Steelbook-list

[Umbrellachef]

Originally Posted by Spect3r

IMO If they are manga/film they shouldnt be part of a videogame list.
But i am not saying that we should do it just because i say it, i am interested in knowing whats the reason that people thinks it should be in the list

:-) and it is a damm good looking one


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk

[Spect3r]

Originally Posted by Umbrellachef

:-) and it is a damm good looking one


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk

That it is

[Codreanu]

Whether it looks good or not shouldn't be a criterion for making it on a list for video game steelbooks. The steelbook comes with the novel, not the game. There's not even a way to put the game's disc in it.

[sinanspd]

Originally Posted by Codreanu

Whether it looks good or not shouldn't be a criterion for making it on a list for video game steelbooks. The steelbook comes with the novel, not the game. There's not even a way to put the game's disc in it.

What about the Playstation Plus one for example? That also doesn't have a a disc slot. I am honestly indifferent to the situation but if I had to make a choice I would probably vote to keep it for now. I think the difference between the manga ones and this one is that the game came first and the novel followed, whereas for manga/movies it is almost always the other way around. But it is a very thin line so I wouldn't be mad if it was removed.

My current logic is flawed such that, if the uncharted movie gets a steelbook release, we would need to add that (it probably will given Tom Holland's popularity) and it's down hill from there.

[Spect3r]

Originally Posted by sinanspd

What about the Playstation Plus one for example? That also doesn't have a a disc slot. I am honestly indifferent to the situation but if I had to make a choice I would probably vote to keep it for now. I think the difference between the manga ones and this one is that the game came first and the novel followed, whereas for manga/movies it is almost always the other way around. But it is a very thin line so I wouldn't be mad if it was removed.

My current logic is flawed such that, if the uncharted movie gets a steelbook release, we would need to add that (it probably will given Tom Holland's popularity) and it's down hill from there.

To me is not the fact that it has a disc slot or not, it was more a question of why a Novel was part of the list but mangas, etc weren't.
That the Novel only exists because of the Game it's true, and that is not necessarily a bad rule to follow.
I was just trying to understand the criteria.

[Umbrellachef]

Originally Posted by Codreanu

Whether it looks good or not shouldn't be a criterion for making it on a list for video game steelbooks. The steelbook comes with the novel, not the game. There's not even a way to put the game's disc in it.

Let’s make a novel based videogame related steelbook list ;-)


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk

[Codreanu]

Feel free to do so.

[Umbrellachef]

Originally Posted by Codreanu

Feel free to do so.

Thx bro


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk